Welcome to Week 5 of the 2023 season, and the first in our Start ‘Em Sit ‘Em series. This is where it all begins. It’s a chance to get off on the right foot and begin undefeated. As such these decisions are now more fun than ever.
As always, if you are struggling with a decision you can checkout our rankings for each Week. Or, if you want a more personal touch, reach out on social media. You can find us on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram. Or jump into our Discord server. All stats refer to 1/2 PPR, 6 point per passing touchdown leagues. The number in brackets next to an opponent is that teams rank against the position. Rank 1 is the best possible matchup, Rank 32 is the worst. Follow me on Twitter @FFMadScientist
Start’Em
Zach Wilson, Jets v DEN (1)
This is completely and utterly terrifying. Zach Wilson showed the first real signs of improvement last week and is rewarded with the easiest matchup in football. Let’s be clear, this is a desperation, superflex play. He has absolutely no floor, but a blowup game is also within the realm of possibilities.
Sam Howell, Commanders v CHI (2)
In what is essentially his rookie season, Howell has been a rollercoaster of play. He possesses a solid rushing floor that allows him to avoid being a bust in most weeks, but it’s the turnovers that typically determine whether he will be a boom-or-bust.
Jordan Love, Packers v LV (8)
Love completes this trio of young quarterbacks. He has been easily the best of the three but has still been inconsistent. This week he gets to light up a Raiders defense that is brutal. Look for Love to have a top-10 week against Las Vegas.
Sit ‘Em
Trevor Lawrence, Jaguars v BUF (32)
Through four weeks Lawrence hasn’t been bad, but he hasn’t been good either. This entire Jaguars offence just seems to be slightly off. This week they get a tough matchup with the Bills and could see their struggles continue for another week. He’s not a must-sit, he’s just a lower-expectations play this week.
Brock Purdy, 49ers v DAL (31)
Purdy and the 49ers have looked sharp to start the season, so benching him isn’t a reflection of his play. It’s simply a reflection of how good this Cowboys defense is. They are a must-avoid at all costs, start Purdy with caution.
Derek Carr, Saints v NE (28)
Derek Carr is injured, Derek Carr is bad, Derek Carr faces a tough Patriots defense. If those three statements weren’t enough to have you sitting Carr, the fact that the Patriots just traded for JC Jackson to further beef up their defense should.
Start ‘Em
Breece Hall, Jets v DEN (1)
Breece Hall and the Jets skill position players have been a fantasy disaster through four weeks. This week they get the best matchup in football, Denver. If Hall and the rest can’t put up a solid fantasy day in this matchup, then it’s time to cut loose of them in redraft. This matchup should produce a top-12 finish for Hall, if it doesn’t he is unplayable until he proves himself.
Brian Robinson, Commanders v CHI (2)
Robinson has seemingly wrestled the Commanders starting role away from Antonio Gibson. He has been productive, though entirely game-script dependent. Fortunately, he gets an ideal game-script this week against a terrible Bears defense. Look for Robinson to be a high-end WR2.
David Montgomery, Lions v CAR (4)
The Lions have taken a messy D’Andre Swift/Jamaal Williams scenario and traded it in for a messy D’Andre Swift/David Montgomery situation. This situation is going to play out in a similar fashion. Continue to start Montgomery as the touchdown equity alone makes him a high-end RB2.
Sit ‘Em
Dameon Pierce, Texans v ATL (30)
The Texans offence has been on fire, yet Pierce has been bad. It turns out that with CJ Stroud throwing the ball 40+ times per game, they don’t really need him. This week he faces a Falcons defense that has been far better than expected. Sit him in Week 5 as he is more of a flex than anything.
Jonathan Taylor, Colts v TEN (28)
Whether or not Jonathan Taylor will be active and play in Week 5 remains a mystery, regardless he is staying planted firmly on my bench. The Titans have been a brutal matchup for opposing running backs and there’s no way I want to start Taylor in a bad matchup, coming off injury on what could be a snap-count. Sit him for at least a week.
Miles Sanders, Panthers, v DET (27)
Sanders has been inconsistent and average to say the least. He faces a Lions defense that seems to have re-invented itself as a solid unit. The Lions are allowing only 12.4 fantasy points per game to opposing running backs, making Sanders a low-end RB2 option at best.
Start ’em
Rashee Rice, Chiefs v MIN (1)
Four weeks in and a definitive Alpha WR could be revealing himself in Kansas City. Since Tyreek Hill was traded, the receivers have taken turns sharing the production. Rice has seen his productivity increase with each passing week. If he continues to emerge as Mahomes WR1, he has massive breakout potential in an easy matchup with the porous Vikings pass defense.
Zay Flowers, Ravens v PIT (3)
Zay Flowers has been a solid but not spectacular option in the Ravens passing game. He has been more viable than any Ravens receiver has been in years and should continue to be so in a nice matchup with a struggling Steelers team that figures to have the defense on the field for significant stretches. Fire up Flowers as WR2.
DJ Moore, Bears v WSH (4)
Here’s yet another prime matchup for the Bears passing game in Week 5. The Bears offence is bad but back-to-back cupcake matchups should allow them to look serviceable yet again. Start DJ Moore as a mid-range WR2 with upside in an easy matchup with Washington.
Sit ’em
Drake London, Falcons v HOU (31)
London and the Falcons have looked brutal this season. They might be the worst passing game in the NFL. This week they face a Texans run funnel defense that is terrible for opposing receivers. Leave London on your bench in this one, maybe you can even leave him on your waiver wire.
Deebo Samuel, 49ers v DAL (29)
The 49ers offense has been a predictable carousel of production. Samuel, Aiyuk and Kittle seem to be trading off boom weeks while Christian McCaffrey soaks up most of the volume. This week they get a dogfight with an elite Cowboys defense. Sit Samuel unless you have reason to believe this is his squeaky wheel game, which is anyone’s guess.
Nico Collins, Texans v ATL (26)
The Texans offense has been on fire, led by three youngsters in the passing game. Unfortunately the Falcons have been a tough matchup for receivers and coming off a boom week, it’s likely that it’s going to be a Tank Dell week. He isn’t a must-sit by any stretch, he’s just a risky start.
Start ‘Em
Tyler Conklin, Jets v DEN (5)
Conklin has been surprisingly consistent but not elite this season. He’s the definition of a solid, boring streamer. He faces the Broncos this week who are a start-everyone level opponent. If you need a streamer, head back to the Conklin well one more time, even the Jets ball-boy might score fantasy points against this defense.
Zach Ertz, Cardinals v CIN (6)
Zach Ertz is somehow relevant in 2023 despite the Cardinals using high draft capital to seemingly draft his backup. Maybe they’ve been talking to the Detroit Lions too much, I’m looking at you Jahmyr Gibbs. Regardless, Ertz has been a consistent bright spot in the tight end garbage heap and should be a low-end TE1 in a juicy matchup with Cincinnati.
Darren Waller, Giants v MIA (9)
Waller has been a disappointment to start the season, but so has the entire Giants team. Luckily they have a get-right spot against the Dolphins this week who tend to play shootouts on a weekly basis. I don’t expect the Giants to win, but they should all be startable for fantasy, which is all we care about.
Sit ’em
Cole Kmet, Bears v WSH (32)
Kmet was good in Week 4, bad against Denver, who isn’t? He is simply to volatile to trust in a matchup against a Commanders team allowing only 9.7 fantasy points to opposing tight ends. He isn’t a must-avoid, but his floor makes him more of a TE2 level starter this week.
Hunter Henry, Patriots v NO (29)
Henry has been a pleasant surprise this season, but I want nothing to do with either tight end in this game. The Saints have been a nightmare for opposing tight ends allowing only 5.1 fantasy points per game. Henry is going to need a touchdown to make him even a top-15 tight end this week.
Juwan Johnson, Saints v NO (28)
Johnson has the same argument against as Henry, except with a far lower ceiling. If my betting options for Juwan Johnson consisted of betting on him as a top-12 tight end this week or an outside the top-24 tight end this week, I would bet it all on outside the top-24. He is a must-sit this week.
Start ‘Em
Chicago Bears DST v WSH (1)
The Bears are not the team I typically want to stream at defense but this week they face Sam Howell who has been a turnover machine. Add in the low-scoring nature of the Commanders and this could make the Bears a risky, yet productive DST start in Week 5.
Washington Commanders DST v CHI (2)
Th flip side of this game sees the same argument. The Bears struggle to score and Justin Fields struggles to protect the ball. Fire up the Commanders in this matchup and expect mid-range DST1 production is a great matchup.
New Orleans Saints DST v NE (4)
Mac Jones looked terrible in Week 4 and faces a tough Saints defense in Week 5. Look for the Saints secondary to pile up a handful of interceptions. The Patriots also tend to play lower-scoring games so the point against for New Orleans will also likely be limited.
Sit ‘Em
Dallas Cowboys DST v SF (32)
The Cowboys are a top tier DST in the NFL, it doesn’t matter. This week you simply have to leave them on your bench and stream another team. Do not drop them! This is one of the rare scenarios where you have to roster two DSTs for the week.
San Francisco 49ers DST v DAL (30)
Take everything I said about the Cowboys and copy it over to the 49ers analysis. Do not drop them! They are also an elite DST and are also a must-avoid this week. You cannot play them in Week 5, you simply have to stream a second DST in Week 5 and waste a roster spot temporarily.
Cincinnati Bengals DST v ARI (28)
The Bengals offense looks terrible and that has led to their defense spending tons of time on the field. Add in a matchup with a Cardinals team that has somehow managed to be a scary DST matchup and the Bengals have to be sat in Week 5.
Start ‘Em
Cairo Santos, Bears v WSH (1)
This projects as a sloppy game, and sloppy games tend to lead to stalled out drives and field goals attempts. That’s going to be the case here. Start Santos with confidence against Washington.
Matt Prater, Cardinals v CIN (4)
Prater and the Cardinals offense have been serviceable so far, this week they should be outclassed by Cincinnati, but the Bengals have been finding a way to get beat. Look for the Cardinals to hang around long enough to give Prater some field goal equity.
Jake Elliott, Eagles v LAR (6)
The Eagles give Elliott a safe floor based on extra points alone. Add in a few drives where the Eagles take their foot off the gas and settle for a field goal, and he is a prime kicker option in Week 5. He should be a locked and loaded high-end PK1 here.
Sit ‘Em
Brett Maher, Rams v PHI (32)
The Eagles defense is suffocating. The Rams offence is average at best. Once the Eagles crack down on Puka Nacua, this offence is likely to struggle. This will leave Maher with few opportunities to produce. Sit him for better matchups than this.
Jake Moody, 49ers v DAL (31)
Jake Moody has been good as a rookie but I simply don’t want to trust anyone in this heavyweight slugfest. If the offences win out there could be plenty of opportunities to produce, but this is just as likely to be a defensive struggle with limited chances.
Greg Joseph, Vikings v KC (30)
The Vikings defence is terrible, so their offence has to produce to keep them in games. This week they face a bad matchup in the Chiefs who limit kicker production. I prefer to bench Joseph wherever I can.
Well that’s it for our Start ‘Em Sit ‘Em for Week 5 of the 2023 season. Remember, you can check out rankings for each Week. Reach out on social media, you can find us on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram. Or jump into our Discord server. Follow me on Twitter @FFMadScientist
Image Credit: Ed Mulholland – USA TODAY Sports
Start ‘Em Sit ‘Em 2022 Week 14
Start ‘Em Sit ‘Em 2022 Week 14
