Here we have the next DraftKings Showdown slate of the 2024 season- Buffalo @New York. An exciting divisional matchup between the Buffalo Bills and New York Jets, with plenty of fantasy points to be found. Whether you’re locking in a star like Josh Allen as your captain or hunting for value plays like Allen Lazard, there’s a lot to consider.
This game has the potential to be a back-and-forth battle, with both teams leaning on their offensive playmakers. Expect Josh Allen to look to Khalil Shakir early and often, while Aaron Rodgers will lean heavily on Garrett Wilson and Breece Hall to keep the Jets in the fight. The Jets’ defense has been strong, but they’ll have their hands full trying to contain Buffalo’s explosive offense. Meanwhile, Buffalo will be looking to bounce back after a tough loss, setting the stage for an intense showdown in prime time.
DraftKings MNF Showdown 2024 – Buffalo @New York Captain Picks
Josh Allen ($16,500 Capt/ $11,000 Flex)
Josh Allen is coming off a rough game, battling through chest, ankle, and head injuries while completing just 9 of 30 pass attempts. Despite the struggles, Allen’s ability to make plays with both his arm and legs keeps his ceiling sky-high, especially against a Jets defense that could allow him to capitalize on broken plays. Allen is the only quarterback in the league to attempt over 100 passes without an interception this season, showcasing his ability to protect the ball even when under pressure. If he can shake off the pain and get back to his usual self, Allen has the upside to lead all players in fantasy points. Slotting him in as your captain could pay off big, as he’s always a threat to take over the game.
James Cook ($15,300 Capt/ $10,200 Flex)
James Cook enters Monday night’s game with a toe injury, but his limited practice participation on Saturday suggests he’s trending toward playing. If active, Cook’s dual-threat ability as both a rusher and receiver makes him a valuable fantasy play, particularly in PPR formats. He’s been a key part of Buffalo’s offense, and if he can overcome the injury concerns, he’ll likely see a significant workload against a tough Jets defense. Keeping a close eye on his status leading up to kickoff is critical, but if Cook is cleared, he could provide both volume and upside in your captain spot. His versatility gives him the potential for big fantasy numbers if he’s fully healthy.
Garrett Wilson ($15,000 Capt/ $10,000 Flex)
Garrett Wilson saw an enormous 22 targets last week, translating them into 13 catches for 101 yards and a touchdown in the Jets’ loss to the Vikings. While his efficiency was a bit concerning, averaging only 4.6 yards per target, his volume as Aaron Rodgers’ top option in the passing game makes him an elite fantasy asset. Wilson’s involvement will likely remain high, especially if the Jets find themselves in a similar game script where they need to play catch-up. His combination of target share and red zone potential makes him a high-upside captain option. If he can improve his efficiency and continue commanding heavy targets, Wilson could lead all scorers in this game.
Breece Hall ($14,100 Capt/ $9,400 Flex)
Breece Hall is still looking for his breakout game this season, but the Jets’ commitment to a run-first offense under interim coach Jeff Ulbrich provides some optimism. While Hall has been bottled up in recent matchups, the coaching staff’s renewed focus on the ground game could give him more opportunities to shine. His ability to catch passes out of the backfield adds versatility to his fantasy profile, ensuring he stays involved even if the Jets fall behind. Hall’s potential for a heavy workload makes him an intriguing captain option if New York can establish the run early. His ceiling is high, but the risk remains given his slow start to the season.
DraftKings MNF Showdown 2024 – Buffalo @New York Flex Picks
Aaron Rodgers ($9,000 Flex)
Rodgers doesn’t carry an injury designation into this pivotal matchup against the Bills, which is great news for the Jets offense. After some recent shake-ups, including a new play-caller in Todd Downing, Rodgers might see a fresh approach to the offense. The veteran quarterback has struggled to find consistency this season, but with weapons like Garrett Wilson and Allen Lazard, he has the tools to bounce back. Rodgers remains a solid option if you’re looking for a high-upside quarterback play in a divisional showdown.
Khalil Shakir ($8,600 Flex)
Shakir is listed as questionable for Monday night’s game, but his limited practice on Saturday suggests he’s trending in the right direction. If he suits up, Shakir should reclaim his role as a key target in Buffalo’s passing game. His ability to stretch the field could make him a valuable asset against the Jets’ secondary. Be sure to monitor his status leading up to kickoff, as his upside hinges on being fully healthy for the game.
Dalton Kincaid ($8,400 Flex)
Kincaid saw six targets in last week’s loss to Houston but only managed to catch two of them for 34 yards. With Khalil Shakir out, Kincaid tied for the team lead in targets but struggled to convert them into significant yardage. The rookie tight end has yet to surpass 50 yards in a game this season, making him a risky option despite his involvement. Still, his target volume gives him upside, especially if Josh Allen rebounds against the Jets’ defense.
Allen Lazard ($7,300 Flex)
Lazard continues to be a trusted target for Aaron Rodgers, recording four catches on 10 targets for 34 yards and a touchdown last week. Though his yardage has been modest, Lazard remains a red-zone favorite with four touchdowns on the season. With Garrett Wilson drawing the most attention from defenses, Lazard has benefited from opportunities near the end zone. His consistent target share makes him a reliable flex option, especially if the Jets find themselves in another pass-heavy game script.
Keon Coleman ($6,800 Flex)
Coleman flashed his big-play ability with a 49-yard touchdown in last week’s loss to the Texans, though it was his only catch on five targets. Despite inconsistent production, Coleman has two touchdowns in his first five games, showing he can make an impact even with limited volume. With Khalil Shakir still battling an ankle injury, Coleman could see an increased role in the passing game. If Josh Allen gets back on track, Coleman could be a sneaky value play in deeper lineups.
Mike Williams ($5,600 Flex)
Williams was largely invisible last week, catching just two of his four targets for 25 yards in a pass-heavy game against the Vikings. Despite Rodgers throwing 54 times, Williams found himself well behind Garrett Wilson, Allen Lazard, and Tyler Conklin in target share. With the Jets likely needing to throw against the Bills, Williams could see more looks, but his lack of consistent involvement makes him a risky flex play. He’s a dart throw with upside if Rodgers starts spreading the ball more evenly.
Braelon Allen ($5,400 Flex)
Allen had a rough outing last week, rushing just five times for 13 yards and catching one pass for 15 yards. With the Jets shifting to a pass-heavy attack, Allen saw limited opportunities and was out-touched by Breece Hall. In a game where New York may need to run the ball to keep up with Buffalo, Allen could see more touches, but his role remains unpredictable. He’s a risky flex option, especially if the Jets fall behind early again.
Tyler Conklin ($4,000 Flex)
Conklin is questionable for Monday’s game but was a limited participant in practice all week, which bodes well for his chances of playing. He’s coming off one of his best performances of the season, catching six passes for 55 yards in Week 5. If healthy, Conklin could be a sneaky option for PPR formats, especially given his connection with Aaron Rodgers in short-yardage situations. Monitor his status leading up to kickoff, as he could provide great value if active.
Dart Throw Plays (Various)
Here are a few dart plays to round out your lineup. These are high-risk, high-reward picks best suited for GPPs—not for cash games:
- Ty Johnson (RB, BUF) $5,200 Flex – Johnson played a season-high 36% of the offensive snaps last week but managed just three carries for 15 yards. As James Cook’s primary backup, Johnson offers little standalone value, especially with Buffalo frequently needing to pass. He remains ahead of Ray Davis on the depth chart, but unless the game script favors the run, Johnson is a low-ceiling dart throw.
- Ray Davis (RB, BUF) $3,000 Flex – Davis had a minimal role last week, playing only two offensive snaps and catching one pass for four yards. The rookie back has seen his involvement drop off significantly, and he didn’t log a carry for the first time this season. While he remains a handcuff to James Cook, his low snap count makes him a risky dart throw for Monday’s game.
- Curtis Samuel (WR, BUF) $2,800 Flex – Samuel, despite dealing with a toe issue earlier in the week, will be active for Monday night’s matchup against the Jets. While his role in the Bills’ offense has been underwhelming this season, Samuel has managed at least two targets in every game. With Khalil Shakir trending towards playing, Samuel is likely to remain in a depth role, but he could still provide sneaky value in large-field GPPs.
- Mack Hollins (WR, NYJ) $2,400 Flex – Hollins, dealing with a shoulder issue, will suit up for Monday’s game against Buffalo. Despite seeing six targets in each of the past two games, Hollins has turned them into only three catches for 32 yards, making him a boom-or-bust option in this contest. With other pass-catchers healthy, Hollins could be sharing targets, limiting his upside.
- Dawson Knox (TE, BUF) $1,600 Flex – Knox was held without a target for the second time this season in last week’s loss to Houston. Operating as the No. 2 tight end behind Dalton Kincaid, Knox’s opportunities in the passing game have been extremely limited. He’s a risky play, but his occasional usage in the red zone could provide touchdown upside in this matchup.
- Xavier Gipson (WR, NYJ) $600 Flex– Gipson was not targeted in last week’s loss to the Vikings, despite Aaron Rodgers airing it out 54 times. While his contributions in the return game, including a 31-yard punt return, have been valuable, his offensive role remains minimal. He’s an extreme dart throw, but if he can make a splash on special teams, he could pay off in a GPP lineup.
DraftKings MNF Showdown 2024 – Buffalo @New York Kickers and DSTs
Tyler Bass ($5,000)has been a consistent performer for the Bills this season, converting 8-of-10 field-goal attempts and 16-of-17 extra-point tries through five games. In last week’s 23-20 loss to the Texans, Bass nailed both of his field goals, including a 38-yarder in the first quarter. If the Bills’ offense struggles to finish drives against the Jets’ defense, Bass could see multiple opportunities to put points on the board. He’s a solid option if you’re projecting a lower-scoring game with more field goals than touchdowns. Greg Zuerlein ($4,400) made his lone field-goal attempt last week, connecting from 32 yards out in the Jets’ 23-17 loss to the Vikings. Despite limited opportunities this season, Zuerlein remains reliable, having made multiple field goals only once through five games. If the Jets’ offense stalls in the red zone against the Bills’ defense, Zuerlein could become a key contributor. He’s worth considering if you believe the game will remain tight and the Jets will rely on field goals to stay competitive.
Bills DST ($4,600) struggled last week, allowing 331 passing yards and 23 points to the Texans while recording one sack, one interception, and one fumble recovery. While the unit had its hands full with rookie QB C.J. Stroud, they’ll need to tighten up against Aaron Rodgers and the Jets in Week 6. Buffalo’s defense has playmakers capable of generating turnovers, but their secondary has been vulnerable at times. They’re a viable option if you believe they can pressure Rodgers and force mistakes, but their recent form presents some risk. Jets DST ($3,600) played well despite their loss to the Vikings, giving up only 171 passing yards and generating four sacks, an interception, and a fumble recovery. Their numbers were skewed by a defensive touchdown allowed, but overall the unit performed better than the final score indicated. Facing Josh Allen, who has been known to take risks, the Jets could capitalize on potential mistakes. With a strong pass rush and opportunistic secondary, the Jets DST offers plenty of upside in this divisional matchup.
So there you have it — our DraftKings picks for the 2024 Buffalo @New York! Whether you’re locking in lineups or just looking for that edge, we’ve got you covered. If you have any DFS questions shoot me a DM on twitter at @numeric_dfs. Also checkout our other KFS DFS articles here, and interact with us on Twitter, Facebook, or Instagram. We’re always ready to talk shop and help you build those winning rosters!
